Before I go too far, let me say a few things about Joe Thornton. Number one, I like the guy. Everyone said he wasn’t happy to be in Boston, but according to a Providence Journal reporter, every game in Boston, during the national anthem, he would stand between the retired number banners of Milt Schmidt’s #15 and Terry O’Reilly’s #24, because he wanted to have his #19 up there someday. He knew what hockey meant to this fanbase. Even if the city has somewhat abandoned the team (although not entirely… the Pats and Sox stole their thunder, and they did sell out the first few games… it’s just the losing that brings the vitriol and ignorance), he knew that, if he could bring a Cup to Boston, he’d be in the modern pantheon with Brady and Ortiz. Number two, as much as I like him, and as great as his stats are, I think it’s safe to say he’s underachieved in his career so far. Now, I do think he got an unfair rap after the Montreal series. If he sat out, he’d be called soft. If he played, he wouldn’t be effective. He played, he wasn’t effective, and the B’s blew a 3-1 series lead, a dissapointing ending to a team that had the most talent since at least 1999 (with Bourque, Allison, Carter, McLaren, and Sweeney, among others). That being said, he’s had eight years, and while no means a bust, he hasn’t lived up to his potential. For the last five seasons, people have said he’s ready to explode and score 50 goals, but they’ve never come. 2004 aside, he hasn’t produced much in the playoffs. And most recently, after complaining about clutching and grabbing throughout 2003-04 and getting the rule changes freeing up the front of the net, he never took advantage of them. He turtled behind the net every time he had the puck and tried to pass it. Yes, a lot of times, he created scoring opportunities for Murray and Samsonov, but he’s such a talented shooter with such great size and presence, he could be tearing up the scoresheets.
All that being said… I’m sad to see him go. But while everyone is comparing this to the Nomar trade, I think it’s a cross between that and letting Clemens go. Now, obviously, everyone considers letting Clemens sign with Toronto as the fifth biggest mistake in Sox history behind trading Ruth, leaving Pedro in, not trying out Willie Mays and trading Bagwell, but few remember the reason Clemens regained his dominance was out of desire to prove Duquette wrong. I do feel that this is a turning point in Thornton’s career. He will no longer underachieve. He will prove Mike O’Connell and all the doubters wrong, because he now thinks that somehow, the blame for the awful start to the 2005-06 season has fallen on him.
And he will be wrong. The purpose of this trade wasn’t to get rid of Joe Thornton. In 2003, he was behind only Mario Lemieux in jerseys sold. His face was on everything to sell the Bruins. They obviously had no intent of dangling him at the start of the season.
Now, I know it’s impossible to compare sports, but look at the Minnesota Timberwolves. They have the best player in the league (Kevin Garnett), an average one-dimensional player (Szcerbiak) and no-one else. They’ll be lucky to make the playoffs. Now look at the Detroit Pistons. They have a very good point guard, a very good shooting guard, a pretty good small forward, a great power forward, and a dominant defensive center. Their best player is Rasheed Wallace, and he might not be in the top seven PFs in the league, but they have the most balanced lineup, and a deep bench to go with it. Would you rather have the best player in the league and no one around him, or a balanced team of very good players?
Obviously, the situation is different. Thornton had Sergei Samsonov, Glen Murray and Patrice Bergeron to pass to, with Nick Boynton and Brian Leetch to watch his back and Andrew Raycroft in net. This is, at least on a first look, a very good team. The problem is, there’s not much behind that. Brad Boyes will be very good someday, as will Ian Moran and the three young defensemen (whose names escape me now). Apparently, Alexi Zhitnik is a good player, but I haven’t seen it yet. But there is no depth to this team, particularly on defense. Plus, most of their forwards are soft, finesse types who aren’t going to play defense in their own zone.
So what do I think about the trade? I’d like to think they could’ve got more, but look at the aforementioned Nomar trade. Cabrera and Mientkiewicz (Roberts was a separate deal) aren’t very sexy names with stats that aren’t much sexier. Mientkiewicz made great plays when he got on the field, but that was sparingly, and Cabrera slumped for a month before turning on the jets in September and October (then went back to being mediocre in 2005, as the Brawlers can attest). I certainly thought we could’ve got more for a top-3 shortstop (who forgot how to field his position, but we’ll look past that). Look at other hockey trades of big stars. When Gretzky went to LA, Edmonton also had to give up McSorley and Mike Krushelnyski (who averaged about 23 goals a season for a stretch of 8 seasons) and ended up Jimmy Carson (played one full season for Edmonton), Martin Gelinas (decent career) and three #1 picks. Those three picks? Jason Miller (6 total NHL games), Martin Rucinsky (average career, didn’t put it all together until ‘95 for Montreal) and Nick Stajduhar (2 total NHL games). In short… not a very good trade for the Oilers. They gave up the greatest player of all time (yes, they couldn’t afford him, but in hindsight…) for five players, two of which were total busts and the other three failed to contribute for them. Jaromir Jagr, back when he was the hottest commodity in hockey, fetched Kris Beech (one full NHL season, last four in minors), Ross Lupaschuk (3 NHL games, no longer playing in America) and Michael Sivek (3 goals in 38 games, also no longer in the US).
So if we can take comfort in precedence, then this trade isn’t too awful. Marco Sturm is said by some to be the fastest man in the league, and he did net 28 in 2002-03. He was a first rounder, so someone saw something in him. Stuart is one of the better defensemen in the league, even if the scoring isn’t there, with a career plus/minus of +27. He was also a 3rd overall pick, so once again, the potential is there for something great. Wayne Primeau is a good checking line center who can add a little defense. Maybe I’m reaching here, but it could be worse.
So the final verdict? It’s tough. Part of me feels it was just a desperate attempt by Mike O’Connell to save his job, which could very well be true. Sentimentally, I’m partially glad that they didn’t trade Sergei, since the freed-up money could go towards a long-term deal for him. As I said, Thornton’s gonna learn from this and become a great player. He left on good terms, so maybe he can come back as a free agent in three years or some point in the future. I wish him the best (since he’s still on my fantasy team), and I sure as hell hope this trade works out as well for the Bruins as it will for the Sharks.