It’s the question that plagued generations before us. Anyone who watched Gilligan’s Island for an extended period of time has asked themselves the question. It’s more than just an issue of who is hotter. Ginger and Mary Ann represent two different personalities. The question is reflective of one’s self.
When doing that questionaire in my previous post, the questions came up of what we want in (presumably) the opposite sex. It was hard to answer them accurately, hence the vague responses. I was watching Evangelion again last night, and I began to wonder; what is our generation’s Ginger vs Mary Ann debate? It’s hard to come up with one, especially because there has been such a divide among kids of our generation. Some kids would bring up something stupid like Paris Hilton or Nicole Ritchie, even though they are both ugly, stupid spoiled whores. Watching Eva, it made me immediately think of two matchups. Rei vs Asuka, and Tifa vs Aeris (or Aerith). Each matchup represents something different.
Rei is, in terms of the plot around her, probably a more important character to the overall story of Evangelion. Asuka is much more important to the development of Shinji’s character, as both a source of negativity and an object of lust. In terms of looks, Rei is more voluptuous and her facial expressions are usually subdued, while Asuka is rail-thin, leggy, and frequently in a state of anger or aggression, which may turn some people off. While I like Misato more than either of them, I’d have to go with Asuka on this one. I personally think Rei is just a tad hotter, but Asuka is just infinitely more interesting. She’s such a fantastically deep character. Rei gets kinda boring. Also, there’s the whole mother thing…
I think the Tifa-Aeris debate says more about you, though, than the other debates, especially because of the gigantic contrast between the two. Tifa is busty, scantily clad, flirtatious, and, sometimes, a bit ditzy. Aeris is dressed conservatively, despite having a nice body (from what we can tell), and is sometimes shy but predominantly cute.
SPOILERS… ALTHOUGH IF YOU HAVEN’T BEAT FF7 BY NOW YOU ARE A KING BITCH AMONG BITCHES
I think killing Aeris was something that almost needed to happen, assuming Seppy had to kill someone. I don’t think we would’ve felt the same remorse if Tifa was killed. Like some people argue about Kurt Cobain killing himself, Aeris dying was the best career move she could’ve done. She became a martyr. She sent Cloud on a Laser Mission to destroy Sephiroth and he went on to do so without prejudice (although we can assume Seppy was public enemy no. 1 before he jammed a masamune into Flower Girl’s spine). That all being said, I’m a Tifa guy. I like the outrageous personality over subdued. The body certainly helps, but Tifa is, like Asuka, just an infinitely more interesting person.
There are other debates I can think of. Excel or Hyatt (Excel), Chun Li or Cammy (Cammy), Heather Mitts or Jenny Finch (Mitts), Kournikova or Sharapova (Kournikova for now… we’ll see what Maria looks like in a few years, though), and Saria or Malon (Malon). I’m sure there are more…
And yes, I do understand that it’s truly pathetic to speculate on sexual preference over animated or digital females. But hey… that’s what I do.

